Trey: Hello. My name is Trey Smith and I’ve been clean for about 2 years.
Support group: Hi Trey.
Trey: Um, geez, this is really difficult.
Support group leader: Go on Trey, you’re among friends. Just start from the beginning. Tell us how your addiction started.
Trey: Well, it was 2005. I had been rejected by several grad schools, and then committed to go to the University of Sussex in Brighton, England only to have the London School of Economics tell me that I’d actually gotten in to their school after it was too late to back out from Sussex. I guess you could say I was in a dark place intellectually. And that’s when I saw part of the season finale of Lost. I didn’t get what was going on, but it interested me. I was intellectually vulnerable at the time and it seemed smart and entertaining, which is rare in a TV show these days. I remembered seeing the advertisements for it before it premiered and thinking, that’s looks strange. But I didn’t make an effort to watch it because I figured ‘how are they going to keep a show about people on a desert island interesting?’ So I never watched the first season until, by accident, I saw the snippet of the finale for season one. That’s when my life changed. After my grad school let down, I guess was just too weak not to want to see what all the fuss was about.
It started simple enough, I just bought season one on DVD before going to England. Figured since I wouldn’t have a TV it would be a good way to pass the time. Harmless you know? So in England I watched the first episode. It was amazing. I couldn’t wait to see what would happen so I put on the next episode, then the next. My days were consumed with thoughts like, ‘what is that monster thing tearing down the trees?’ and ‘what’s the deal with the others.’ My nights, meanwhile, were spent feeding my addiction by watching episodes.
Support group leader: Did you know that you were addicted to Lost at that point?
Trey: God no! If I did I wouldn’t have … I wouldn’t have …
Support group leader: It’s alright, what did you do?
Trey: I got my girlfriend hooked on it. Man, she was so sweet and innocent! Why God, why?!?!
Support group leader: It’s not your fault, it’s the show’s. Trey, if you’re feeling strong enough, do you think you could tell us what happened next? I think it would really help others facing this addiction to Lost.
Trey: You’re right. I have to be strong so that others might also tear themselves away from this scourge. (deep breath). Ok, well I was on such a high after season one, I mean it was all I talked about and I couldn’t wait for season two. Fortunately my girlfriend had to go back home so she left England before her addiction got to be too much to handle. I, on the other hand, wasn’t so fortunate. My roommate at Sussex had a connection. He could have his friend send him the season two episodes over the internet and we’d watch them on the computer. By that time I was such an addict that the commercial breaks, which you obviously don’t have on the DVDs, drove me crazy, but not as much as the fact that I had to wait a week to see what would happen next instead of just popping in the next DVD. Man, things were such a blur at that point that all I remember was that the season two finale went off the island to show the hot British chick from Desmond’s flashbacks. That straight up blew my mind. I was such an addict at that point that it didn’t bother me that they brought in the ‘tailies’ just to add more characters and thereby add more people to have flashbacks and thereby increase the number of episodes you could have, which would lengthen the series. God, how could I have been so blind!
Support group leader: It was the addiction, Trey. Everyone here was duped just like you.
Anonymous support group member #1: Yeah, I was too addicted to notice that the monster from season one was barely an issue in season two.
Anonymous group member #2: You know I was too strung out on Lost to care that at least half the episodes in season two had absolutely nothing in them to advance the plot of the show.
Support group leader: Exactly. And what about that episode with the couple who buried a diamond or something on the island and then got buried alive after being bitten by a spider? That made no sense and had nothing to do with the story at all but at the time our addictions didn’t let us apply reason to the events. So we just kept watching like the addicts we were.
Trey: Yeah, the application of reason was suspended by our addiction and actually that’s how I managed to break Lost’s hold on me. The summer of 2006 I went home to write my MA dissertation and was reunited with my girlfriend. Not only hadn’t she seen season two, but she was also working on a dissertation. That summer I had to really use my reasoning ability to come up with arguments for my dissertation and got to spend time with my girlfriend who is intellectually challenging. We talked about all sorts of things, politics, life, culture; everything except Lost. For the first time in a long while I realized that Lost had suspended my ability to think critically. By the time my girlfriend left, I didn’t really care about Lost. Most importantly, at that time I was neck deep in writing my dissertation, which reacquainted me not only with reason but with what good writing is suppose to look like.
I remembered that in writing a paper there should be a clear purpose and that the arguments to prove your point should be well formulated and follow from one another. The points didn’t have to be completely linear, in fact complicated subject matter often means that your points will be somewhat jumbled. But by the end it should all fit together like a puzzle to form a definite, understandable and reasonable conclusion. Most importantly, I remembered that the dissertation should only be as long as it needed to be. If the argument is only going to take 50 pages, don’t put in a bunch of filler to make it 70 pages. Just because one paper is longer than another doesn’t mean it is better. A good dissertation is tightly put together, which means it will only go on as long as it has too.
Anonymous group member #3: So then you quit just like that?
Trey: I wish. That fall, once my dissertation had been handed in, season three started and I relapsed. I guess I still wasn’t strong enough to face down my addiction at that point. I just had to know what was going to happen with the British chick and Desmond, he was my favorite character. So I watched the season three premier. But something was different. I wasn’t getting as high from Lost anymore. It annoyed me that they didn’t answer questions but instead kept creating more questions. I couldn’t stop watching at that point, but it did force me to reach what they call ‘rock bottom.’ I kept watching Lost, but it just made me mad. I would yell at the TV and go into a funk after every show because they didn’t reveal anything meaningful. It was just more questions, and more stand alone episodes, and more flashbacks from characters that were boring.
What really helped me was that basketball season started and by the Grace of God the Duke games had a tendency to coincide with the day and time Lost was on. So I didn’t get off the junk cold turkey, but by the end of 2006 I was totally off Lost and back to living my life; clean and sober.
Support group: (applause)
[All the while a young man has been sitting in the back listening to Trey speak and rolling his eyes in disdain and just generally being restless and fidgety. He now stands up and points his finger Trey.]
Jeff: You people are so weak minded. Addicted to Lost?!?! Give me a break! I love the show and I’m not addicted. You people just can’t see that it is an amazing piece of entertainment that boggles the mind and you are too much of a sissy to handle your mind being boggled. I’m reasonable, I manage to lead a perfectly healthy life, and I love Lost and can see that it is good writing and speeding toward what will be the series finale event of our lifetime!
Support group: (grumbling)
Trey: Hold on guys, its ok. I know this guy, he and I used to talk about Lost before I kicked the habit.
Jeff: Yeah, and I still watch Lost every week and try to figure out what’s going on with my other friends, which is fun and you’re just jealous because you can’t join in the conversation.
Trey: Jealous?!?! No, just sad for you. Look, if it were good writing there wouldn’t be wasted episodes would there? And yet, there are tons of so-called ‘character developing’ episodes that don’t advance the plot as far as what’s happening on the island. Moreover, if it were really going to develop the characters, the flashbacks would have to reveal something meaningful about the person. Instead, they just create more questions about them. So instead of creating full and robust characters, they end up creating increasingly aloof and mysterious characters.
And let’s address that ‘mysterious’ aspect that the show thrives on. You and other addicts, and I was one so I’d know, will say things like ‘the show is sooo good because I don’t know what will happen next.’ Have you ever been around a 5 year old and asked what they did that day? They ramble on about all sorts of crap that has no bearing on the next thing they mention. Thus, it is impossible to guess what they’re going to say next. So not being able to predict what is going to happen next does not in itself represent brilliant writing or story telling.
Jeff: That’s a straw man argument. The writers know what is going on, JJ Abrams and the other producers said so.
Trey: So you just take a producer at their word huh? George Lucas said Indy 4 wouldn’t suck balls, how did that turn out? Producers only want money. That’s their job, to make the show or movie into a product that will rake in money. For a producer, good writing is subordinate to that end. A great example of this would be the movie Mission Impossible 3. The plot was going fine and dandy until the end. To save money, or maybe just to appear artsy, the second to last action sequence is where Tom Cruise has to break into this building to get a biohazard container with something really dangerous in it from the bad guys. But to cut back on length and money, they only show Cruise break into the building and then don’t show how he gets the container but rather cut to two people in the car outside talking and then Cruise jumps out of the building with the container. So you’re robbed of a potentially cool action scene for the sake of cost cutting. Wait, it gets worse. At the end, he has recovered this container and the MYSTERY is what is inside this thing that is so dangerous. But they don’t tell you. Cruise asks what’s inside it and his boss just says, ‘we’ll tell you later.’ That’s crap! And you know who produced that garbage, JJ Abrams.
To Abrams and his cohorts MYSTERY is just a means to keep you interested, not to create a good story. When I was addicted to Lost there were mysteries about what the monster was, why it only killed some people, and why it existed. Then you got to see the monster and it turned out to be black smoke that was either alive or controlled by someone. Um, I’m sorry did I miss something in science class? A black smoke that can tear up trees and kill people? How are the writers going to explain that? They can’t! They are just going to say MAGIC and call that an explanation. The best case scenario is that they explain it using some sort of pseudo science like remote viewing. My question to you is how satisfactory is that going to be having watched this show all the way through only to be told that it’s mysteries are explained by quack science.
Jeff: They aren’t going to end the show by saying, MAGIC. They might use pseudo science, but it will all make sense in the universe that they’ve created.
Trey: Ah ha! But isn’t a great deal of the pleasure you derive from Lost a result of trying to figure out what’s going on or what’s going to happen? And if they are going to use scientific rules that they are making up on the fly, then it’s impossible for you to figure out how to explain anything. They keep you guessing only because you don’t know the rules, you don’t have insight to their random thoughts just like you don’t have access to the thought process of a 5 year old telling a story.
What’s more is that the show is written by a team of writers working independently. So one guy might come up with a show and have new mysteries crop up and even if that writer sees how to resolve that mystery later, the next episode is written by another writer who creates his own mysteries. So you end up with a bunch of different mysteries made up by different writers and even if they all knew how to resolve their own mysteries, the individual resolutions may not make sense inside the larger whole of the show. One resolution may jibe with another resolution.
So just admit that there is no way that Lost is going to end in a way that answers all the mysteries it has created in a way that will be satisfactory to anyone that has a 6thgrade understanding of physical science or realizes that good story telling is able to come to a conclusion that resolves the problems it has set up without bringing in ‘evidence’ or ‘explanations’ that weren’t made available to the audience.
Jeff: No.
Trey: Ok well at least admit that the show would be improved if instead of trying to stretch it out to 7 seasons they made it 4 seasons. Admission of that is the first step toward recovery because you realize that they are extending this just to make more money then you’ll realize that the quality of writing has taken a backseat to profits, which entails that mysteries have to be cooked up to keep you interested and whether or not they can resolve those mysteries in a reasonable, well written way is unimportant.
Jeff: Maybe it would be better if it was only 4 season, but that doesn’t mean that I should quit the show. I’ve already invested so much in it. I mean when I think of all the time I’ve spent watching the show and looking at internet forums that theorize how the mysteries will be solved using pseudo science … oh my God, what have I done with my life! I mean I’m the guy who had to explain Stephen Hawking’s book to you because I understood it and you didn’t totally get it. There’s no way I’ll be happy with an ending that uses pseudo science to explain things. I mean Locke heard a voice from an invisible guy in a rocking chair and I thought nothing of it. What have I become!!!
Trey: It’s ok man, it’s ok. This is the first step toward shaking off the addiction to Lost. We’ve all been there and it’s hard, but once you quit you’ll go back to the rational and thoughtful person you used to be.
[The entire support group stand up, go over to Jeff and embrace him in a group hug while Trey remains standing at the podium in the front of the room.]
Jeff: Thank you so much Trey, and thanks to the rest of you for being so supportive. [Jeff closes his eyes to fight back tears and to feel the comfort of a group hug. Suddenly, Jeff opens his only to realize that there is no one hugging him. The only people in the room are him and Trey.]
Jeff: What the … Where did everyone go!
Trey: Ha! This room is built upon a super magnetic plate deep within the earth that allows me to control your mind and force you to see things that are not actually there. The other people in the group were images that I projected into your mind. Once you entered this room you were at my mercy because even though there is a way out, I can erase it from your mind with my telepathy. So you don’t see the exit door even though it does exist in reality. Now you will remain here forever while I control your mind and have my scientist friends run experiments on you. Hahahahahahaaa!!!!!!
Jeff: That’s stupid and doesn’t really make much sense!
Trey: You want to know how it makes sense: MAGIC!!!
This play was produced by JJ Abrams and written by JJ Abrams in conjunction with George Lucas.